Re: Looking for success stories
Because dogs are essentially Type 1 diabetics, diet is not truly critical to their regulation the way it might be with a Type 2 diabetic (cats are more like Type 2 diabetics).
The prescription diets work well for a lot of dogs but so do many other diets. It's a matter of balancing the way an individual dog absorbs insulin and how that dog absorbs the food given. Both vary greatly dog to dog. Sometimes a very high glucose carb is needed.
I personally am not convinced that the health of people or dogs is influenced nearly as much by diet as we (society) think it is. It is tempting to fiddle around with diet because it's one of the few things we have complete control over and so we tend to want to invest it with a great deal of power.
But for every study that comes out saying something is good for you or bad for you, there is another study saying the opposite. So the "truth" probably is best described as "we don't know."
And the diets of people who live long healthy lives run the gamut from greasy meat and potatos and pie every day (some are my relatives) to organic holistic vegans. I talked to a lady yesterday whose mother lived to be 100 years old. She said that her mother went her entire life eating whatever she wanted, rarely went to a doctor, and only occasionally took the one med she was ever prescribed, for high blood pressure.
I think genetics has a lot more to do with it than we want to think.
Short answer is that I don't think there is a diet for longevity in a dog, diabetic or otherwise, (or a human) other than one that's decent quality ingredients and covers their nutritional requirements to the best that we understand them.
Natalie
Because dogs are essentially Type 1 diabetics, diet is not truly critical to their regulation the way it might be with a Type 2 diabetic (cats are more like Type 2 diabetics).
The prescription diets work well for a lot of dogs but so do many other diets. It's a matter of balancing the way an individual dog absorbs insulin and how that dog absorbs the food given. Both vary greatly dog to dog. Sometimes a very high glucose carb is needed.
I personally am not convinced that the health of people or dogs is influenced nearly as much by diet as we (society) think it is. It is tempting to fiddle around with diet because it's one of the few things we have complete control over and so we tend to want to invest it with a great deal of power.
But for every study that comes out saying something is good for you or bad for you, there is another study saying the opposite. So the "truth" probably is best described as "we don't know."
And the diets of people who live long healthy lives run the gamut from greasy meat and potatos and pie every day (some are my relatives) to organic holistic vegans. I talked to a lady yesterday whose mother lived to be 100 years old. She said that her mother went her entire life eating whatever she wanted, rarely went to a doctor, and only occasionally took the one med she was ever prescribed, for high blood pressure.
I think genetics has a lot more to do with it than we want to think.
Short answer is that I don't think there is a diet for longevity in a dog, diabetic or otherwise, (or a human) other than one that's decent quality ingredients and covers their nutritional requirements to the best that we understand them.
Natalie
I would take some form of readily available glucose on your walks with you when you go.
Comment